re-visiting the colonialism debate.

by Siena Anstis on June 2, 2026 · 4 comments

in Africa

Reacting to a line in Niall Ferguson’s book Colossus: The Rise and Fall of the American Empire - “Sub-Saharan Africa, in particular, has been impoverished not by the oft-denounced legacies of colonialism but by decades of misrule since independence” - my brother asked me: “Would the situation in Sub-Saharan Africa be any different if you take colonialism out of the picture?”

At first, I had a series of pretty loose arguments. The usual go-to - colonial powers drew arbitrary boundaries across ethnic lines - is over-argued. So, out of curiosity, I looked up a few essays on colonialism and its effect on Africa. After reading a few pages of an essay by Peter Ekeh called Colonialism and the Two Publics in Africa: A Theoretical Statement (1975) (“one of the most cited publications in the field of African studies, inside and outside Africa,”) I could not help but react.

This may be (let me get to the end of the essay first), the most important sentence in it:

The civic public in Africa is amoral and lacks the generalized moral imperatives operative in the private realm and in the primordial public.

You could say that without the imposition of an English organizational and moral system, a country like Kenya or Uganda would have had the opportunity to absorb unavoidable external changes such as population growth, food shortages and so on through the flexibility that existed in their private organizational and moral realm, the community.

By having the opportunity to do so, they would have had - in large part - the participation of a majority of the population in this process. In the long run, this would have probably led to more stability. Or, at minimum, an indigenous system to draw upon when developing mechanisms for peace-building and negotiation for a wider regional grouping consisting of many communities.

Imagine that you are a full participant of your Canadian neighbourly community. This community offers immediate support and resources in terms of making ends meet. You rely on it for moral guidance on the decisions you make in life and follow its rules through a long established principle that not following these rules will leave you to public skewering. Even more importantly, you operate primarily as a community and not as an individual.

Then imagine that mythical nation-builders called Gobblers come over. They are purple in colour (thereby distinctively different from anything you know) and have a new organizational system with different morals.

Only the Southern half of your country is absorbed into the Gobbler civil service system. People joining do so by a mix of greed and curiosity. In the long run, these civil service men become Gobblers in their means of organization. They also adopt, in a sense, Gobbler morals - currency is power and value, the individual operates primarily for himself/herself etc. Let’s say there is nothing wrong with these values, but they are alien to the other half of the population.

The Northern side of the population, including yourself and those not absorbed into the civil service, operate on a parallel level. Instead of engaging with the Gobblers - total weirdos really - they continue to operate in their own system. This system continues to dictate most rules of community (and largely family life as well). External circumstances such as population growth and food shortages are dealt with by the community itself with little to no interaction with the Gobbler civil service. Cattle raiders attack nearby communities; farmers die; families share.

One day, the Gobblers leave. However, the leave behind a system of governance which can be used for tapping resources in your country after their departure. Initial participants in this civil service have command over a section - the country - drawn arbitrarily by the Gobblers. Participants - Members of Parliament, Presidents - have adopted Gobbler organizational values and morals which remain alien to a majority of the population.

Thus, and you encounter this in Ngugi’s book Petals of Blood, there are now two spheres to society. The traditional system which governs community relations between community, families, individuals etc. and the civil service which operates on its own distinct level and does little to actually regulate or control the communities they are intended to organize and govern. The link was largely never made between these two bodies. There was limited to no opportunity for the two systems to grow into each other or develop a complimentary relationship.

This would be a small piece in the puzzle of why governments in Kenya and Uganda can pillage coffers, create new and expensive districts, stuff ballots, buy votes and so on with little to no direct moral condemnation. People may rail and rant about what they do, but politicians are so far from being an actual part of the practical world (the world of the traditional community), that their actions are merely vaguely critiqued and then absorbed. Or, agreement is bought or forced.

So, would colonize Sub-Saharan countries be any different? Perhaps. The Gobblers had a strong role in creating these two parallel systems and botching any opportunity (at the time of great external changes) for these communities - soon to be countries - to learn how to absorb and accommodate.

I do say though, particularly now with the global spread of information, that these communities have a unique opportunity to begin demanding a contract between state and public. The system is now deeply rooted enough that perhaps the principles of it will not change; however, it is no longer enough for a government to operate on a different sphere from the communities they “govern.” And here is when people stop blaming colonialism (which they have in large part) and start demanding that this contract be enforced.

So, once again, would the Ugandans and Kenyans be any different? I think so.

They would most likely not still be searching for an indigenous system of rule that applies to all spheres of society. It is safe to say that Ethiopia has adapted to the challenges of many centuries, proceeding from powerful kingdoms to somewhat democracy. During this time, the state and community had an opportunity to develop a regional understanding of this state-public contract rather than an initial period where one operated completely unaccountable to the other.

Undoing the last part is proving to be very, very difficult.

I think Sub-Saharan Africa finds itself in an opportune time to start building this social contract. Reactions on the above argument, though terribly holed, and Sub-Saharan Africa’s need for better governance are welcome.

{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }

Laura @ Texas in Africa June 3, 2026 at 9:38 pm

First of all, kudos on finding the Ekeh article; it’s a classic and one that I assign to my African politics students. In political science, we often talk about the state-society divide, which is kindof (though not exactly) what Ekeh discusses. I do think that colonialism created a divide in the public sphere between what people really believe about how their societies are organized and what the law says they believe about the same.

Would Africa look the same were it not for colonialism? Certainly not. But the same could be said about slavery, or the colonization of the Americas, or the colonization of ancient Italy. I’m more interested in how we bridge the gaps that we already know exist.

Reply

Siena Anstis June 3, 2026 at 9:55 pm

Thanks for the comment! And pardon if this is disjointed. Two nights in an airport and I should be on computer less arrest.

I was listening to some podcasts on the evolution of international law today and it reminded me of the state-society divide once again. The speaker was talking about universality - both in terms of jurisdiction, but I also think in terms of local understanding of the ICC.

Anyways, Ekeh’s essay - in some ways - could also characterize the divide between local and international justice systems. The latter, in Uganda at least, is is primarily a vestige (though perhaps a useful one) of a colonial past. There exists some of the same corruption between law and society as there exist between government and society. Respect for international legal mechanisms in very isolated places is about on par with Petals of Bloods’ description of MPs in rural Kenya. Completely divorced from each other.

Anyways, in terms of bridging the gaps we know exist, I think the interplay between these two legal systems (one more familiar to the decision-makers behind the court and the other based in custom) is an interesting case. And, I guess we are seeing a consideration of this in the application of international law - gacaca, the mato oput debate etc.

And, what I’m getting at — Perhaps here is an opportunity to integrate, or better coordinate, two systems that could potentially run parallel of each other ensuring similar lack of accountability as the Ekeh dilemma.

Reply

Laura @ Texas in Africa June 3, 2026 at 11:49 pm

That’s a good point. It’s interesting, though, that much of the research on gacaca courts, for example, is showing that people don’t really accept the results - or see the courts as a legitimate expression of “traditional justice.” The Hutus see it as something imposed on them by the Tutsi government, while the Tutsis see it as a way that those guilty of genocide “get off” without significant punishment. Maybe that’s a bad example given the specific circumstances of Rwanda; it would be interested to think about bridging these gaps in less divided circumstances…

Reply

Siena Anstis June 5, 2026 at 6:27 pm

Well put. In Northern Uganda, it transpired - well, through brief interviews I did for an article in 2007 - that there was also a generational (on top of ethnic/cultural) divide on the practice of mato oput. Furthermore (and there’s a fantastic CARITAS video discussing this that you must see - do email Prof. Todd Whitmore for the title), some children were concerned about the process as they felt they had not done anything wrong on their own desire (drugs, being at gun point etc. being factors that forced their actions).

I guess in the long run, perhaps, these two levels of law (custom/international) can interact together provided enough cross-fertilization of ideas and experiences. There was a recent post on Enough, I believe, talking about the ICC review conference that, once again, brought up the debate peace first and justice after, or the reverse. I suppose circumstances will dictate the approach. I hope the ICC - the over stretched body it seems to be - has the capacity to tackle these difficult questions. What do you think?

Reply

Leave a Comment

Anti-Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Previous post:

Next post: