All posts in Advocacy

Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum

The US Supreme Court is hearing a very important case today. The Guardian UK has provided a brief commentary here. Essentially:

In Kiobel v Royal Dutch Petroleum, a group of Nigerians claim that they or their relatives have been the victims of torture, summary execution and other crimes against humanity perpetrated by the Nigerian government with the active collaboration of the oil company. The suit was brought under the Alien Tort Statute, a 1789 law that allows aliens to sue in US courts for torts in violation of international law, under which dozens of cases have been brought since it came back to life in a 1980 decision of the court of appeal for the second circuit.

The same court has now ruled that the ATS applies only to individuals, as in the 1980 case, but not to corporations. The supreme court will have to decide whether it agrees with this rule, or with those of four other circuits, none of which have had any difficulty taking on corporate human rights cases under ATS.

Some additional comments from Huffington Post:

Attorney Kathleen Sullivan, representing Royal Dutch Petroleum, faced intense questioning from Justice Elena Kagan that highlighted the irreconcilable divide between the two sides’ arguments. Sullivan contended that there was no norm of corporate liability in international law courts and conventions, while Kagan said that silence in the international sources did not create corporate immunity.

Making Docile Lawyers

A colleague recently sent me an article titled “Making Docile Lawyers: An Essay on the Pacification of Law Students” (you can find a copy here). In summary, it describes the “re-socialization” process that Harvard Law students undergo during their legal education. The focus is on the “pacification” of these students: transforming them from high achievers with specific ideals and goals - often oriented towards social justice - to students resigned to a B grading curve and relieved by any job offer (usually from a corporate recruiter). It may be of interest to current or future law students, particularly those who have decided to invest in a legal education for the purpose of social justice.

The author’s observations are applicable not only to Harvard Law, but also McGill’s Faculty of Law, and I assume many other law schools. I found that this article raised three key questions: (i) How does the “socialization” process in law school affect the way one advocates for social justice?; (ii) To what extent can one integrate field placements or work in social justice outside the Law Faculty into our legal studies?; (iii) How does one maintain a notion of “self” within the rigid institutional structure of law school, particularly during the first year?

The first question pertains to the lens in which we view the law. During the first year of law school, I think most students were told that legal analysis requires putting aside emotions and gut reactions and applying reasoned, structured legal analysis to a problem. Intervening in class with the notion that something was “unjust” or “unfair” (even if this is at the heart of a judge’s reasoning and directly informs the Court’s holding and the law generally) was not welcome. As a lawyer, we would be expected to - similarly - advocate on behalf of a client by using established legal reasoning tools. The message of fairness and justice would have to be implicit. The issue of reconciling this “neutral” framework with one’s desire to advocate more tangibly for change is at the heart of this question.

The second question asks whether there is a way to marry the experiences one has outside the classroom with those in the classroom. One quickly learns that the law - at least the way it is taught in classrooms - is highly abstract. A majority of professors tend to prefer it remains this way. Field placements, on the other hand, often require dealing with administrative and technical challenges one never faces in the classroom. For example, if you are working in a country where the legal system is highly corrupt and dysfunctional, can you really draw on your legal reasoning abilities to advocate for a client? Is advocacy through the legal system even an option? Field placements also often provide an opportunity to develop highly specialized knowledge about a specific issue or region. However, to what extent is the institution flexible enough to allow you to develop this knowledge into a report or briefing paper rather than an essay based on a more theoretical abstraction?

The third question addresses the structure of law school itself. As the author points out, it is largely a return to high school: you are surrounded by the same colleagues, you have a permanent space (locker), there are set timetables and assigned professors, and one may be expected to attend a number of social activities. There is also a structured trajectory: after completing your second year, you begin the recruitment process for firms in Québec or common-law provinces. There are organized on-campus recruitment drives for summer positions with corporate firms and the occasional government position. Clerkship applications begin in the Winter semester of your third year. Much of what happens at the Faculty is organized around a fairly fixed notion of what the institution believes a law graduate becomes: a first year associate at a firm. Of course, there are a number of opportunities while in school that permit you to explore your interests including summer clinic positions, a human rights internship program, research centres, legal journals and a variety of student groups to engage with. However, none of these bodies provide the same type of professional and financial security after graduation in the way that corporate law firms do. In other words, other trajectories aren’t facilitated or encouraged to the same degree and it is distinctly more difficult to find your own “niche” outside these formal systems.

Behind the MDGs.

Villages in Action is happening this weekend in Kikuube, Uganda. This unique conference is in response to the Millenium Development Goal summit in 2010 where world leaders and experts came together to discuss the plight of the poor - but forgot, yet again!, to include them. Villages in Action brings this community front and center as activists, facilitators and organizers.

Personally, I was quite struck by a series of Twitter Q&As on @tmsruge’s handle. A number of young girls from the Kikuube community were given access to the Internet and had the change to ask questions to other young women around the world. Their concerns and curiosity - from both the girls in Uganda and those responding in other areas of the world - are touchingly similar: innocent questions from a young woman in rural Uganda to another in D.C. I’m hoping they will be published on the Villages in Action website later so you can read them as a whole.

Upcoming human rights events in Montreal.

In October at the McGill Faculty of Law:

Radha D’Souza on “Imperial Agendas, Global Solidarities and Third World Socio-legal Scholarship: Methodological Reflections.”

 | October 3, 12.30 -2.00 PM, Room 202, New Chancellor Day Hall.

Azim Hussain on “Fraternity and the Debate regarding the Face-Veil: France, Belgium, and Quebec in Comparative Perspective | October 19 in room 316, New Chancellor Day Hall, McGill Faculty of Law, between 12.30-2.00 PM.

Human Rights Working Group: Welcome & Fundraising Potluck

This Magazine: “Postcard from Cambodia: How a new law threatens Canada’s aid to millions.”

Just up on THIS Magazine. Based on a previous article published in the Guardian (UK), this post takes a closer look at Canada’s role in the Cambodian draft NGO & Associations Law.

 

Representing human rights defenders in Cambodia

Sunrith Ham, Deputy Director of Monitoring & Protection at LICADHO, works with a number of human rights victims in Cambodia including the Dey Krahorm community (pictured above). Members of the community were evicted from their land in 2009 for ‘development purposes’ and moved to a relocation site. Their former land remains vacant.

At first face, working as a lawyer in Cambodia seems like a disheartening experience. Corruption is endemic: the rich and powerful bribe judges to have cases found in their favor and use criminal sentencing to deter resistance from members of the community. The police, acting under the instruction of the government, often comply in the harassment and arrest of human rights activists.

Someone recently asked me why anyone would continue working within such a broken legal system. I think Sunrith’s story is a good example of how coping with difficult circumstances in the hope of helping suffering individuals starts with a personal decision – one intimately connected to culture and religion. In the end, perhaps change makers are not inspired by a single defining event, but rather an uphill struggle led by instinct.

Sunrith graduated with a legal diploma from a Phnom Penh university in 1997 at the age of 22. The government appointed him as a law clerk in his hometown. As a government employee, he was making $20 USD a month. His first experience with the evolving Cambodian legal system was not a positive one. He recounts how a woman’s child was arrested and arraigned in front of the judges. The mother offered them a bundle of money carefully tied with a rope made from banana leaves. The money had clearly been saved up – diligently, meticulously, through hardwork. She bought her child’s freedom; the judges did not complain.

Religion and culture can deeply influence a person. In Cambodian culture, and particularly in Buddhist families, youth are taught to obey their superiors. But, Sunrith was different. He felt he had received two messages: to listen to people older than him; but also to question decisions like those made by the judges at the provincial court. He says his religion, Buddhism, also helped him make the difficult decision to leave his clerking position: “I didn’t feel like I was doing a good thing. I felt that if I was not making people feel better, I was not taking the right route.”

His parents were surprised by his decision. As a class-conscious family in a class-conscious society, they were delighted that their son had found work with the government. Despite this family pressure, he left this position to permanently move to Phnom Penh, the country’s growing capital, some 160 km away.

Sunrith’s first job was as a typist. At first, he was content. He was financially independent as the new job paid more than the government. However, after a few months, he began questioning his decision: should someone with a diploma in law work as a typist? Could he push himself to do more?

Soon he decided to leave his relatively comfortable position as a typist and began volunteering and then interning withLICADHO. He spent the first five years working with the Prison Office. Cambodian prisons, notorious for their horrific living conditions, became a second home to him. While others would express fear or disgust towards prisoners, Sunrith was happy to talk with them, bringing them bananas to help the day past faster. Seeing people energized and rewarded by his presence clearly made him happy.

Eventually, Sunrith transferred to LICADHO’s Human Rights Monitoring Office and this helped him make the decision to become a practicing lawyer. “You see injustice from case to case, but as an observer [a human rights monitor who tracks human rights abuses] you cannot express yourself, you are not in the system.”

Sunrith says that some days he is exhausted and considers leaving the legal profession. Yet, his friends and colleagues convince him that if he stops working, human rights defenders will have a difficult time finding a trusted lawyer to represent them free of charge. Around LICADHO, Sunrith has the reputation of a formidable lawyer: someone with a chilling confidence in front of the Cambodian Supreme Court, the country’s highest judicial body.

While he acknowledges that changing old societal practices would be difficult, he does believe that he can help change the attitude within the courts in Cambodia. To fight corruption and injustice, Sunrith hopes that the next generation will not be taught to accept the orders of their superiors, but rather to question authority. He says that future legal professionals should not concentrate on whether or not there is law, but rather on implementing the existing law and abiding by the rules set out within.

Working with LICADHO, Sunrith, who has been in the thick of human rights activities in Cambodia since the late 90′s, does note some positive changes. He says that the number of political killings has decreased substantially. Rather, the government is now using the courts to dissuade people from challenging them. The fact that the government’s weapon is no longer primarily the gun, but rather the law, is seen as a step – although a twisted one – forward.

Watching community activism in action also seems to give Sunrith renewed hope. He speaks admiringly of the communities living around Prey Lang forest who came all the way to Phnom Penh a few weeks ago to protest the destruction of their forest. He advises the residents of Boeung Kak lake, another community being evicted from their land, to believe in their struggle. “How can you change injustice? How can you change the attitude of the government? Hope comes day to day, from the people. It does not come from institutions or the policymakers.” He says that while Boeung Kak lake residents may lose their homes, in the end, they have set a fighting precedent that will hopefully grow and overcome the “cancer”of corruption and exploitation ailing the country.

Cross posted on the McGill Centre for Human Rights and Legal Pluralism blog.

the nuanced story?

Adam Hoschild’s book “Bury the Chains” left me with many questions on today’s advocacy and human rights movements. In his closing chapter, he refers to the use of human emotion and empathy to spur action. He refers to the evidence brought forth by the abolitionists, including this very famous picture of a slave ship.

We use similar (now photographic and video) images to communicate conditions of poverty and inequality to the world at large. These, in turn, often help raise donations, which are used in humanitarian programs, aid and development spending. The use of these images is being debated. In particular, whether these images reinforce inaccurate blanket stereotypes about other people, cultures and nations.

The author of “Bury the Chains” does flag this tension. But, he never seems to take a firm stance and oscillates between commending the abolitionists’ methods while also suggesting they were not revealing the whole story. For example, Hoshchild talks about the Wedgewood anti-slavery medallion and notes that this was one of the most popular symbols of anti-slavery at the time. He also notes that there were a number of former slaves who were powerful activists and did not identify with this image (like Equiano, who is featured regularly throughout the book) and that, in practice, it was primarily female slaves who suffered the brunt of slavery.

What tools do advocacy movements use today to offer a more accurate and/or nuanced picture? Does the Internet help or hinder this?