All posts in Law

Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum

The US Supreme Court is hearing a very important case today. The Guardian UK has provided a brief commentary here. Essentially:

In Kiobel v Royal Dutch Petroleum, a group of Nigerians claim that they or their relatives have been the victims of torture, summary execution and other crimes against humanity perpetrated by the Nigerian government with the active collaboration of the oil company. The suit was brought under the Alien Tort Statute, a 1789 law that allows aliens to sue in US courts for torts in violation of international law, under which dozens of cases have been brought since it came back to life in a 1980 decision of the court of appeal for the second circuit.

The same court has now ruled that the ATS applies only to individuals, as in the 1980 case, but not to corporations. The supreme court will have to decide whether it agrees with this rule, or with those of four other circuits, none of which have had any difficulty taking on corporate human rights cases under ATS.

Some additional comments from Huffington Post:

Attorney Kathleen Sullivan, representing Royal Dutch Petroleum, faced intense questioning from Justice Elena Kagan that highlighted the irreconcilable divide between the two sides’ arguments. Sullivan contended that there was no norm of corporate liability in international law courts and conventions, while Kagan said that silence in the international sources did not create corporate immunity.

Making Docile Lawyers

A colleague recently sent me an article titled “Making Docile Lawyers: An Essay on the Pacification of Law Students” (you can find a copy here). In summary, it describes the “re-socialization” process that Harvard Law students undergo during their legal education. The focus is on the “pacification” of these students: transforming them from high achievers with specific ideals and goals - often oriented towards social justice - to students resigned to a B grading curve and relieved by any job offer (usually from a corporate recruiter). It may be of interest to current or future law students, particularly those who have decided to invest in a legal education for the purpose of social justice.

The author’s observations are applicable not only to Harvard Law, but also McGill’s Faculty of Law, and I assume many other law schools. I found that this article raised three key questions: (i) How does the “socialization” process in law school affect the way one advocates for social justice?; (ii) To what extent can one integrate field placements or work in social justice outside the Law Faculty into our legal studies?; (iii) How does one maintain a notion of “self” within the rigid institutional structure of law school, particularly during the first year?

The first question pertains to the lens in which we view the law. During the first year of law school, I think most students were told that legal analysis requires putting aside emotions and gut reactions and applying reasoned, structured legal analysis to a problem. Intervening in class with the notion that something was “unjust” or “unfair” (even if this is at the heart of a judge’s reasoning and directly informs the Court’s holding and the law generally) was not welcome. As a lawyer, we would be expected to - similarly - advocate on behalf of a client by using established legal reasoning tools. The message of fairness and justice would have to be implicit. The issue of reconciling this “neutral” framework with one’s desire to advocate more tangibly for change is at the heart of this question.

The second question asks whether there is a way to marry the experiences one has outside the classroom with those in the classroom. One quickly learns that the law - at least the way it is taught in classrooms - is highly abstract. A majority of professors tend to prefer it remains this way. Field placements, on the other hand, often require dealing with administrative and technical challenges one never faces in the classroom. For example, if you are working in a country where the legal system is highly corrupt and dysfunctional, can you really draw on your legal reasoning abilities to advocate for a client? Is advocacy through the legal system even an option? Field placements also often provide an opportunity to develop highly specialized knowledge about a specific issue or region. However, to what extent is the institution flexible enough to allow you to develop this knowledge into a report or briefing paper rather than an essay based on a more theoretical abstraction?

The third question addresses the structure of law school itself. As the author points out, it is largely a return to high school: you are surrounded by the same colleagues, you have a permanent space (locker), there are set timetables and assigned professors, and one may be expected to attend a number of social activities. There is also a structured trajectory: after completing your second year, you begin the recruitment process for firms in Québec or common-law provinces. There are organized on-campus recruitment drives for summer positions with corporate firms and the occasional government position. Clerkship applications begin in the Winter semester of your third year. Much of what happens at the Faculty is organized around a fairly fixed notion of what the institution believes a law graduate becomes: a first year associate at a firm. Of course, there are a number of opportunities while in school that permit you to explore your interests including summer clinic positions, a human rights internship program, research centres, legal journals and a variety of student groups to engage with. However, none of these bodies provide the same type of professional and financial security after graduation in the way that corporate law firms do. In other words, other trajectories aren’t facilitated or encouraged to the same degree and it is distinctly more difficult to find your own “niche” outside these formal systems.

Public order bill in Uganda

An interesting article on the Public Order Bill in Uganda. The theme - the use of legislation to crackdown on government critics and to exercise greater control over people’s rights to assemble and protest - is familiar. While working in Cambodia over the summer, I analyzed and studied the Cambodian Peaceful Assembly bill, passed in 2009, which has similar provisions (see pages 10-11 of this report & an article I wrote a few months ago). In particular, the establishment of procedures is susceptible to abuse.

Mpagi, writing in the Ugandan Monitor:

According to the explanatory memorandum for the Bill, it among others “seeks to manage public order” and to “specify the procedure to be followed when organising an assembly, a procession or demonstration as well as the penalties and sanctions to be imposed upon those found to breach the proposed law.”

Mr Solomon Webaalearaali, a human rights lawyer with Street Law Uganda, says that alone means that government is seeking to take away what ideally is the essence of demonstration as a means of expressing dissatisfaction in a democratic society.

“Public demonstration has an element of spontaneity, but this law will seek to establish procedures like applying for permission to demonstrate and if you are denied by the police then you go through an appeal process and then a court process; that takes away the purpose of demonstration, imagine people wanted to demonstrate because they took a mother to deliver in Mubende and she was not attended to and she died, do they have to wait and go through all those processes?”

Of course, the rule by law issue is at the heart of the debate. Is the government using new legislation to consolidate its power in the face of protests while placing itself above the law?

Critics of the Bill say these provisions effectively take away any automatic right for people to assemble and questions government actions or inactions. Those jittery about the Bill in its current form say they are concerned that government is increasingly resorting to rule by law rather than rule of law. They argue that the spirit of the new law is a panicky reaction to increasing public pressure on government expressed through demonstrations especially over the last six years.

Cambodian Government Uses NGO Law to Silence Critics

I just published an article which is basically an abstract of the major essay I wrote on ‘repressive legislation’ in Cambodia as a conclusion to the internship. You can view the original here and an abstract below:

In late July the Cambodian government released a third draft of its highly contentious Law on Associations and Non-Governmental Organizations (NGO Law). A number of provisions in the law have the potential to impair the activities of human rights and civil society actors in the country.

The draft law, in a likely violation of freedom of expression which is protected both in the Cambodian Constitution and the ratified International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), makes it mandatory that any group of Cambodians (including clubs and networks) operating as a non profit in Cambodia register with the government. These bodies also have to fulfill a number of complex and technical registration requirements. If they fail to do so, the government has a ‘legitimate’ excuse to prevent them from operating. The Cambodian League for the Promotion and Defense of Human Rights (LICADHO), a human rights organization operating across Cambodia, dubs this approach the “tyranny of the technicality” and believes it is likely that the government will use this power to shut down entities advocating for human rights or reporting on government corruption.

For ‘informal networks’ or loosely associated groups of individuals like farmers and taxi drivers, who do not have the means to open bank accounts or have formal office addresses, these requirements could severely impair their ability to register. It may force a majority of them to operate illegally, rendering them even more vulnerable. These networks are key partners in the development process, providing first-hand information on the situation of at-risk groups in the country and assisting international donors who continue to fund about half of the Cambodian government’s budget.

While these concerns may seem speculative, there have already been a number of recent situations foreshadowing what is to come. For example, the Ministry of Interior, without any clear justification, arbitrarily closed an NGO called Sahmakum Teang Tnaut (STT). A few weeks before, the NGO had published a report finding that the compensation offered by the government to households affected by a government railway project and slated for resettlement was too low.

LICADHO’s director, Naly Pilorge, perhaps best summarized the overall effect of the NGO Law were it to pass: “Everything that would happen to informal networks under the draft law is already happening now [like STT being shut down]. If the law passes, it legalizes these restrictions.”

Repression through new laws

Activists believe the NGO Law is representative of a larger trend by the Cambodian government to use ‘repressive’ legislation to impair freedom of expression and assembly.

During his recent unofficial visit to the country, Frank La Rue, the UN Special Rapporteur on freedom of expression and opinion, dubbed this emerging Cambodian style of governance a “legal dictatorship.” Surya Subedi, the current UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in Cambodia, has called it a “legal offensive.”

Along with the NGO Law, the new Penal Code and the Law on Peaceful Assembly also facilitate this trend of repression through the courts in Cambodia.

Commenting on the Penal Code, the Cambodian Minister of Information, Khieu Kanharith, said: “Before, using the argument of ‘freedom of expression’ and opposition party status, some people could insult anybody or any institution. This is not the case now.”

Human rights bodies in Cambodia are particularly concerned by the possibility that Penal Code provisions like incitement to commit a felony and defamation will be indiscriminately used to silence activists in the same way the crime of disinformation under the former UNTAC Criminal Code was applied.

Two recent cases justify this concern:

A LICADHO staff member was charged with incitement during his appeal hearing in July. Originally charged with disinformation for distributing anti-Vietnamese pamphlets, the judge not only violated international fair trial standards, but also clearly affirmed that the court believes that this type of political leafleting can actually constitute an act to cause unrest in Cambodia or ‘incitement.’

A second case is that of Seng Kunnaka. In December 2010, Kunnaka, an employee of the World Food Program, was convicted on a charge of criminal incitement under the new Penal Code for printing and sharing material from KI-Media, an online blog that aggregates information critical of the government. He was sentenced to six months in jail and a $243 fine.

The third ‘repressive law’, the Law on Peaceful Assembly, is primarily giving the authorities a means to isolate and neutralize protests. The law provides for the creation of “Freedom Parks” across Cambodia. These parks are assigned zones for peaceful protests of up to 200 people. They are typically isolated from heavily trafficked areas. Authorities use the existence of these parks as an excuse to disperse peaceful assemblies not happening within their confines.

[Continued]

Third draft of the Cambodian Associations & NGO law out

Last week, the Cambodian government released a third draft of the Associations & NGO law. LICADHO’s commentary on this draft of the law can be accessed here. The International Centre for Not For Profit Law (ICNL) has also released a brief analysis available here. In summary, the key issue - the fact that it makes registration mandatory - remains.

LICADHO makes the following recommendations:

• Registration must be voluntary. The law’s mandatory registration provisions violate Cambodia’s own Constitution, international norms, and multiple international conventions which Cambodia has ratified. It also puts the NGO Law in direct conflict with several other Cambodian laws, creating a confused, impossible-to- navigate legal landscape for all groups wishing to assemble or undertake a broad array of activities in Cambodia.

• The law should specify that organizations and associations are temporarily authorized to operate while their registration applications are pending.

• The government must articulate a justification for the law, particularly in light of Cambodia’s 2007 Civil Code. The current stated purposes in Article 2 are entirely unsatisfactory: “giving” rights that Cambodians already possess, and providing opportunities that already exist.9 Stating a coherent justification will allow Cambodia’s legislators the ability to assess the stated purpose of the law and determine whether it is merited or whether modifications are warranted.

The law has moved to the Council of Ministers, which in Cambodia is the final stage of review before a law moves to the National Assembly for ‘debate’ (Hun Sen’s party, the Cambodian People’s Party has a majority and it is highly unlikely that the debate would lead to the necessary amendments, or anything else fruitful). For more updates on the law, “like” the Oppose the Cambodian NGO & Associations Law page.

Human Rights Working Group 2011-2012


This fall, I will be one of the General Coordinators for the Human Rights Working Group at the McGill Faculty of Law in Montreal, Quebec. We will be hosting a number of interesting human rights-related events through our seven portfolios covering international justice, immigration & refugee law, responsabilité et réforme policière and droit et incapacité.

The Human Rights Working Group is a diverse collective of student advocates. Its purpose is to promote human rights education at the Faculty and on the McGill campus; to raise awareness of and reduce human rights violations within the wider community, and to assist law students in finding employment opportunities in the field of human rights and social justice.

  • If you would like to volunteer with HRWG, please contact the relevant Portfolio for more information.
  • If you are interested in speaking at the Faculty or would like to suggest a speaker, please email us at hrwg.law(@)mail.mcgill.ca.
  • Starting in September, HRWG sends out a weekly newsletter with upcoming human rights events, speakers, and internship opportunities so please send us any interesting contributions.
  • “Like” us on Facebook and receive regular human rights news updates (and contribute your own).

Regional Symposium on the Criminalization of Free Speech, Expression and Opinion in Asia in Jakarta, Indonesia

On July 15 and 16, I attended the Regional Symposium on the Criminalization of Free Speech, Expression and Opinion in Asia in Jakarta, Indonesia. The symposium marked the end of Frank La Rue’s, the UN Rapporteur on freedom of opinion and expression, visit to the Southeast Asian region.

The symposium covered a number of different themes, from repressive legislation (one of the key concerns in Cambodia) to threats faced by human rights activists and the State sanctioned killing of journalists.

Decriminalize Free Speech

La Rue opened the symposium with a clear message: free speech needs to be decriminalized. Authoritarian regimes used to employ force to intimidate the population. However, this came at a huge political cost and these regimes are now “intimidating with the law.” La Rue underlined that the international community, including the United Nations, has not opposed this tactic forcefully enough.

The Special Rapporteur emphasized that he believes exceptional limitations on freedom of expression are necessary, but these should only be used in a democratic society (notably one where the judiciary is capable of interpreting the law according to international standards). For example, the use of incitement to crackdown on pamphleting in Cambodia is “absurd.” Where censorship is necessary – for example, with hate speech and child pornography – an independent body, and not the State, should apply these exceptions. “When government gets to control content, it goes to the benefit of political power. These censorship laws become an excuse for governments to limit freedom of expression,” said La Rue.

Repressive legislation and impunity

One of the key themes emerging from all panels, with delegates representing Southeast Asia and South Asia, was the use of legislation to undermine the work of human rights activists, as well as the total impunity of those who commit human rights violations.

In Thailand, the lèse majesté law is a key concern. Pravit Rojanaphruk, a journalist from Thailand, explained how the line between defamation and criticism of the monarchy is blurred. There is also no transparency as to the number of people detained under the law. A recent estimate stood at 300 people charged with an estimate 11 detained. Naturally, the threat of criminal sanctions under the law has a ‘chilling’ effect on freedom of expression.

In Cambodia, three enacted laws (and two laws in draft form) give the government significant control over civil society. A discussion between Kek Pung, the President of LICADHO, and delegates demonstrated the total absurdity of the situation. Pung asked for suggestions on how to address this issue in Cambodia. The panelists offered some feedback, all deemed inapplicable in the Cambodian context: the friendly parliamentarians are the opposition, but their leader, Sam Rainsy, is in exile. Commissioners at the ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights’ (AICHR) are appointed and dismissed by national governments. Donors are mum, some in collusion with the government while others do not want to rock the boat.

In Malaysia, a mix of secular and religious laws are used to crack down on minority religious groups, as well as political movements and more liberal Muslim groups. “Silencing opinion and expression in Malaysia happens not only for crimes against religion, but all forms of dissent against government policies and political powers. It is not peculiar for the government to crackdown on defaming Islam, because they do so on all forms of difference in opinion, period,” explained Masjaliza Hamzah, Executive Director of the Center for Independent Journalism in Malaysia.

Ending human rights violations

In his closing speech, La Rue listed concrete suggestions on how CSOs and NGOs could end government impunity and promote human rights. He drew primarily on experiences in Guatemala, his home country.

For example, he suggested the establishment of independent national investigative bodies such as the International Commission Against Impunity in Guatemala. While this Commission does not have the power to prosecute, it does the investigatory work in human rights crimes. He also suggested persuading each country to adopt a national human rights commission.

La Rue also discussed the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. Although it was at first riddled with its own set of challenges, he praised it for providing justice and in some cases saving lives. He compared this to the ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights (AICHR), which was founded in 2009, and has been described as toothless. La Rue suggested that having the mechanism in place is a first step; regional civil society bodies should now push the AICHR by referring cases and lobbying for greater impartiality in its commissioners.

As a Special Rapporteur, he highlighted the role these individuals play in highlighting human rights abuses. For example, issuing a press release during a Rapporteur’s visit can serve to draw media attention to certain issues. He noted that the Special Rapporteurs can go beyond their immediate mandate, allowing them to leverage a relatively ‘non-political’ mandate. For example, the Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights to Safe Drinking Water and Sanitation can deal with everything from water containment to land evictions and the role of big corporations in environmental pollution.

Encouraging a grassroots movement

While interesting, these suggestions seemed to illustrate how intractable the situation is in Cambodia. NGOs like LICADHO are drawing on all the resources suggested by the Special Rapporteur. Yet, this is not enough.

However, it does seem that one last avenue, not specifically mentioned by La Rue, has not been sufficiently leveraged. In retrospect, it seems self-evident: the population needs to start lobbying on a mass scale for change and civil society groups need to promote and support this. However, abuse by the police and unfair criminal sentencing by the judiciary has a damning effect on these efforts. Moreover, people have not forgotten the country’s harsh history.

Yet, there is proof that such lobbying is possible and (somewhat) effective: in 2008, a nation-wide thumb printing petition campaign collected over one million signatures in favor of passing the long-awaited Anti-Corruption law. While the law was not adopted until 2011, it does suggest that there is a population willing to be mobilized and capable of organizing itself.

 

LICADHO employee, Leang Sokchouen, at the Phnom Penh Court of Appeal

Leang Sokchouen at the Phnom Penh Court of Appeal. Photo by LICADHO.

Yesterday, I attended Leang Sokchouen’s trial at the Phnom Penh Court of Appeal. Sokchouen is a LICADHO employee who was charged with disinformation (under the UNTAC Penal Code) in September 2010. Here an extract of the LICADHO press release issued after the trial court ruling:

Sokchouen was accused of distributing anti-government fliers in Takeo Province on January 4, 2010. Sokchouen was a longtime acquaintance of co-defendant Tach Khong Phoung, but consistently testified that he had no knowledge on the flier incident. The so-called evidence provided by the police against Sokchouen consisted of a simple list of phone numbers claiming Sokchouen and Tach Khong Phoung had called each other.

Another defendant, Tach Vannak, initially claimed while detained at the Ministry of Interior’s National Police that Sokchouen was involved in distributing the fliers.

However, Vannak retracted part of his statement in court yesterday, saying that he only implicated Sokchouen because of false promises made by police interrogators. He claimed police promised him that he would be allowed to go back to his family in exchange for his cooperation.

(…) The prosecution produced no in-court witness testimony or evidence. The judge relied entirely on written statements and four alleged witness statements from police officers. None of these individuals were ever called to court by the investigating judge.

By all appearances, the investigating judge did not do any investigative work on the case whatsoever. This is contrary to the spirit of Article 127 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which states that an investigating judge “has the obligation to collect inculpatory as well as exculpatory evidence.” This oversight left the trial judge to rely entirely on police investigation report - written before the suspects were questioned or arrested.

Conversely, the Sokchouen’s defense team provided extensive in-court testimony, including evidence that Sokchouen was in Phnom Penh - not Takeo - on January 4, 2010.

The judge stated that in-court testimonies by the three accused “could not be trusted” and based his decision entirely upon the police report and interrogation. Article 118 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states that police reports can be used for “information only,” but that they may also be considered as evidence if they are not “proven false.” Despite strong evidence that the police report was indeed false, the judge failed in his duty to evaluate its veracity. He simply accepted the report as truth.

In appeal, Sokchouen was represented by two LICADHO lawyers, who were given less than 24 hours to prepare. During the hearing, Sokchouen’s lawyers requested bail. However, after a five minute discussion, the judges refused citing possible public disorder. The judges, along with the defence, interviewed Sokchouen. In under two hours - with two of the judges regularly dozing off - the court announced that their final verdict would be communicated on July 14th at 8am. While about 100 people showed up to support Sokchouen, only a small number were allowed in the court room despite it being a public trial.

Sous Chantha, union leader, released from prison

Trade union leader Sous Chantha’s wife holds a press conference after her husband’s trial on Friday, June 24th 2011.

When I first arrived in Phnom Penh, I was invited to attend a ceremony in support of Sous Chantha, a Cambodian union leader. Along with his family and other garment factory workers, we went to a pagoda near CC1 and participated in a Buddhist blessing. A crowd of friends, family and supporters then walked to the correctional center and released balloons. The hope was that Chantha would see them as they floated above the prison walls. At the time, Chantha had been held a month longer than provisional detention allows in Cambodian law (unless there is a formal hearing to renew provisional detention with a maximum of 12 months total).

Yesterday, I attended Chantha’s trial at the Phnom Penh Capital Court of First Instance. Chantha was first accused of drug trafficking, but the charges were eventually lowered to drug distribution (some believe this change happened because it was blatantly not trafficking, others because of pressure from unions and companies buying from Cambodian garment factories).

The facts laid out in LICADHO’s press release shortly after his arrest were confirmed during the trial by Chantha and a garment worker who had witnessed the events (he was on a motorbike behind Chantha when the arrest happened). The garment worker said that the police had beaten Chantha after forcing him off his motorbike. Chantha said the military police had “turned him away” (translation from Khmer) from his motorbike. It is likely that Chantha did not use the same language as the witness in order to not attract more trouble. When Chantha was allowed to turn around again and look at his motorbike, the police shone a flashlight on the back hatch and accused him of having drugs. All Chantha could see was the corner of a small plastic packet near the motorcycle’s battery; the other nine packet of drugs were only revealed to him when he arrived at the police station. Both Chantha and the witness confirmed that there was indeed no roadblock at the time of Chantha’s arrest. Notably, the military police who had arrested Chantha failed to show up at the trial.

In their closing statements, the defense lawyers argued that Chantha could not be convicted for the distribution because this would require evidence of a buyer. Moreover, it was possible to slip a thin plastic baggy of drugs into the back of the motorcycle without actually opening it (i.e. it could have been done in the factory parking lot which is a public space). The defense lawyers also emphasized the suspicious nature of the arrest: it happened shortly after he transferred his union’s 1000 members from the Independent & Democratic Union Federation (IDUF) to the Coalition of Cambodia Apparel Workers Democratic Union (C-CAWDU). The prosecutor argued that because Chantha claimed during the trial to not do drugs at all, by default the drugs must have been meant for distribution.

After about two hours of questioning and an hour-long wait, the judge called Chantha back in and announced the verdict. They found him guilty. He was sentenced to ten months in jail, but ordered only to serve seven months and five days in prison. Since this was the time he had spent in pre-trial detention and the prosecutor decided not to appeal, he was released that evening. As Chantha walked out of the court at midday to be brought back to the prison before being released, he was applauded by a garment factory workers and his family. His father started crying.

From my understanding of the trial (through a translator) there was no evidence to support distribution charges. The following day, the Cambodia Daily reported that “local and international rights groups, including Amnesty International, raised doubts over the charges and said that they seemed to be linked to his union activities. Some said the arrest served to intimidate unionists.” Moeun Tola, from the Community Legal Education Center, was also quoted in the Cambodia Daily: “We’re not happy with the verdict. It’s unfair for him, an injustice for him that he was charged with drug distribution. We still believe his case was set up.” The presiding judge, Din Sivuthy, has been involved in previous human rights cases with suspicious (and “shocking”) verdicts (see this acid attack case and journalist Hang Chakra’s conviction).

Chantha was released from prison yesterday evening. After participating in a Buddhist ceremony, he returned home to his family after having spent over seven months in prison.

This Magazine: “Postcard from Cambodia: How a new law threatens Canada’s aid to millions.”

Just up on THIS Magazine. Based on a previous article published in the Guardian (UK), this post takes a closer look at Canada’s role in the Cambodian draft NGO & Associations Law.

 

Using new laws to impair freedom of expression in Cambodia

This past week I started writing a brief on the use of repressive legislation in Cambodia to restrict freedom of expression and related rights like freedom of association and assembly. With a majority in Parliament, the ruling Cambodian’s People Party has passed or is about to pass legislation that could be used to legitimize their crackdown on human rights defenders, NGOs, journalists and other concerned parties critical of the government.

Penal Code

The new Cambodian Penal Code was passed in December 2010. It replaces the former UNTAC Penal Code. While the new Penal Code does not contain the same UNTAC disinformation clause (which has been used to jail journalists and wrongfully convict other individuals), it creates a number of new crimes susceptible to abuse. This includes a provision for “incitement” which is defined as incitement to commit a crime or incitement of “serious turmoil in society.” Shortly after the passage of the new Penal Code, World Food Program staff member Seng Kunnaka was convicted on the charge of criminal incitement for printing and sharing material from the website ki-media, an online blog critical of the government [Incidentally, as I write this, my access to ki-media is down again. There are rumours the government is having it blocked]. The government is not hiding one of the new Code’s purposes: “Before, using the argument of ‘freedom of expression’ and opposition party status, some people could insult anybody or any institution. This is not the case now,” said the Cambodian Minister of Information.

For a more in-depth analysis of the new Penal Code provisions, check out this report.

Demonstrations Law

The Demonstrations Law was adopted in 2009. It makes it de facto necessary to receive authorization to protest. Demonstrations can be refused if they harm the rights to “freedom and honour of others, good customs of society and national security”. This differs from the ICCPR article which allows for limits on demonstrations only on the basis of “public safety, public order, public health or morals.” Moreover, the law fails to provide judicial redress in cases where authorization is refused. The Centre for Cambodian Human Rights Report also suggests that the law has been used before to crackdown on private meetings. Finally, and possibly the most disconcerting part of the law for the moment, is the creation of “Freedom Parks” across the country. These “Freedom Parks” are areas where protestors can hold protests after providing 12 hours notice. While the parks do not exclude the use of other public venues, there are concerns they may still be used to isolate and neutralize demonstrations.

Anti-Corruption Law

The third law is the Anti Corruption Law passed in May 2011. While a number of corrupt officials have been charged under the law, there are allegations that these charges are more related to factional splits in the ruling party than to corruption in Cambodia. A number of provisions are problematic. In particular, the law does not provide adequate protections for whistleblowers and thus discourages people from coming forward.

Draft Trade Union Law

The draft law contains a number of provisions that offer the government an opportunity to legitimize their crackdown on the trades union sector through the courts. Several articles of the law blatantly violate the International Labor Organization Convention No. 87 (see this article by article analysis of the law). Key concerns include the inclusion of criminal penalties and hefty fines that could be used to threaten union leaders from speaking out against the government. Vague language contained in the law could also be used by the government to curtail freedom of expression. For example, the provision outlawing demonstrations for “purely political purposes” could be used to prevent legal demonstrations or strikes in opposition of government policies.

Draft Associations and NGO Law

This law is currently in draft form, but it is expected that the government will try and pass the law before the end of the year. In violation of freedom of association protected under the Cambodian Constitution and the ICCPR, the law enforces the mandatory registration of associations and NGOs (see this analysis by LICADHO). It also imposes a number of burdensome registration requirements, which would severely restrict the operation of rural grassroots groups with limited resources. It gives authorities unbounded discretion to approve registration applications, with few guidelines to transparently steer these decisions. There is no appeals process if registration is denied. The law is also loosely drafted, giving it an apparently unlimited scope.

In its current form, the law would likely lead to the outlawing of several informal groups which do not want to register with the government or do not have the capacity. These informal networks give a voice to a number of vulnerable groups including sex workers. The likely closure of grassroots NGOs and associations, which provide information to international donors, could impair economic development in Cambodia. With the press muzzled and the private sector often complicit in human rights violations, NGOs are the last body able to report on human rights abuses and corruption in Cambodia.

Apparently a couple of embassies in Phnom Penh (but not the US embassy), when first faced with the Associations & NGO Law, thought it was a perfectly reasonable law to have in place. After all, many Western countries do have some kind of Association and NGO law. What they failed to consider was the Cambodian context. Most importantly, there is no judiciary to enforce the law fairly (see Cambodia’s recent ranking as 35/36 on the World Justice Project Rule of Law Index) or to create a body of precedent that would narrow or at least purposively develop the ambiguity of many of these provisions. Rather, new laws give the government something to point at when they decide to shut down an NGO, move a protest to a Freedom Park or fine a union leader. New laws make it harder to argue that the government is acting out of bounds.

The content and opinions expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of nor are they endorsed by LICADHO or its affiliates.

Representing human rights defenders in Cambodia

Sunrith Ham, Deputy Director of Monitoring & Protection at LICADHO, works with a number of human rights victims in Cambodia including the Dey Krahorm community (pictured above). Members of the community were evicted from their land in 2009 for ‘development purposes’ and moved to a relocation site. Their former land remains vacant.

At first face, working as a lawyer in Cambodia seems like a disheartening experience. Corruption is endemic: the rich and powerful bribe judges to have cases found in their favor and use criminal sentencing to deter resistance from members of the community. The police, acting under the instruction of the government, often comply in the harassment and arrest of human rights activists.

Someone recently asked me why anyone would continue working within such a broken legal system. I think Sunrith’s story is a good example of how coping with difficult circumstances in the hope of helping suffering individuals starts with a personal decision – one intimately connected to culture and religion. In the end, perhaps change makers are not inspired by a single defining event, but rather an uphill struggle led by instinct.

Sunrith graduated with a legal diploma from a Phnom Penh university in 1997 at the age of 22. The government appointed him as a law clerk in his hometown. As a government employee, he was making $20 USD a month. His first experience with the evolving Cambodian legal system was not a positive one. He recounts how a woman’s child was arrested and arraigned in front of the judges. The mother offered them a bundle of money carefully tied with a rope made from banana leaves. The money had clearly been saved up – diligently, meticulously, through hardwork. She bought her child’s freedom; the judges did not complain.

Religion and culture can deeply influence a person. In Cambodian culture, and particularly in Buddhist families, youth are taught to obey their superiors. But, Sunrith was different. He felt he had received two messages: to listen to people older than him; but also to question decisions like those made by the judges at the provincial court. He says his religion, Buddhism, also helped him make the difficult decision to leave his clerking position: “I didn’t feel like I was doing a good thing. I felt that if I was not making people feel better, I was not taking the right route.”

His parents were surprised by his decision. As a class-conscious family in a class-conscious society, they were delighted that their son had found work with the government. Despite this family pressure, he left this position to permanently move to Phnom Penh, the country’s growing capital, some 160 km away.

Sunrith’s first job was as a typist. At first, he was content. He was financially independent as the new job paid more than the government. However, after a few months, he began questioning his decision: should someone with a diploma in law work as a typist? Could he push himself to do more?

Soon he decided to leave his relatively comfortable position as a typist and began volunteering and then interning withLICADHO. He spent the first five years working with the Prison Office. Cambodian prisons, notorious for their horrific living conditions, became a second home to him. While others would express fear or disgust towards prisoners, Sunrith was happy to talk with them, bringing them bananas to help the day past faster. Seeing people energized and rewarded by his presence clearly made him happy.

Eventually, Sunrith transferred to LICADHO’s Human Rights Monitoring Office and this helped him make the decision to become a practicing lawyer. “You see injustice from case to case, but as an observer [a human rights monitor who tracks human rights abuses] you cannot express yourself, you are not in the system.”

Sunrith says that some days he is exhausted and considers leaving the legal profession. Yet, his friends and colleagues convince him that if he stops working, human rights defenders will have a difficult time finding a trusted lawyer to represent them free of charge. Around LICADHO, Sunrith has the reputation of a formidable lawyer: someone with a chilling confidence in front of the Cambodian Supreme Court, the country’s highest judicial body.

While he acknowledges that changing old societal practices would be difficult, he does believe that he can help change the attitude within the courts in Cambodia. To fight corruption and injustice, Sunrith hopes that the next generation will not be taught to accept the orders of their superiors, but rather to question authority. He says that future legal professionals should not concentrate on whether or not there is law, but rather on implementing the existing law and abiding by the rules set out within.

Working with LICADHO, Sunrith, who has been in the thick of human rights activities in Cambodia since the late 90′s, does note some positive changes. He says that the number of political killings has decreased substantially. Rather, the government is now using the courts to dissuade people from challenging them. The fact that the government’s weapon is no longer primarily the gun, but rather the law, is seen as a step – although a twisted one – forward.

Watching community activism in action also seems to give Sunrith renewed hope. He speaks admiringly of the communities living around Prey Lang forest who came all the way to Phnom Penh a few weeks ago to protest the destruction of their forest. He advises the residents of Boeung Kak lake, another community being evicted from their land, to believe in their struggle. “How can you change injustice? How can you change the attitude of the government? Hope comes day to day, from the people. It does not come from institutions or the policymakers.” He says that while Boeung Kak lake residents may lose their homes, in the end, they have set a fighting precedent that will hopefully grow and overcome the “cancer”of corruption and exploitation ailing the country.

Cross posted on the McGill Centre for Human Rights and Legal Pluralism blog.

Sous Chantha, Cambodian union leader, still in pre-trial detention

Six months ago, Sous Chantha, Cambodian union leader and former employee of United Apparel Garment factory, was arrested. This arrest happened shortly after he transferred his union’s 1000 members from the Independent & Democratic Union Federation (IDUF) to the Coalition of Cambodia Apparel Workers Democratic Union (C-CAWDU). A brief history of the case can be found here. The gathering today - a ceremony at the adjacent wat followed by the release of balloons outside the prison where Chantha is being detained - marked the fact that he has now spent exactly six months in provisional detention on drug trafficking charges. Information gathered by LICADHO strongly suggests that Chantha was framed in retaliation for changing his union’s affiliation.

Some people at the ceremony were saying that an international boycott of the factory’s products was leading to renewed pressure on the government to resolve this situation. Shortly after Chantha’s arrest, Clean Clothes Campaign posted an “Urgent Action” request here. However, it is not clear from research online whether there is an actual international boycott in progress and what effect this is having. Also, from what I was explained today on the criminal law system in Cambodia, the Court must hold a pre-trial detention hearing now that Chantha has been detained for six months (I believe Article 208 of the Cambodian Criminal Code). In serious cases, they may extend his provisional detention.

Ath Horn, Head of C-CAWDU, speaking before the ceremony at the wat.

Sous Chantha’s daughter.

During the ceremony at the wat.

Sous Chantha’s daughter during the ceremony.

Walking towards the correctional center where Sous Chantha is detained.

Releasing balloons for Sous Chantha to see from within the prison.

The content and opinions expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of nor are they endorsed by LICADHO or its affiliates.

Cambodia’s troubling NGO & Associations Law

Civil society organizations in Cambodia, including LICADHO, continue to fight against the imminent passage of a repressive Associations & NGO Law. The first draft of the law, released in December 2010, was condemned by the international community “as an assault on Cambodians’ right to freedom of association, assembly and expression.”

The second draft of the law, released on March 24, is no improvement. Naly Pilorge, Director of LICADHO, describes some of the fundamental difficulties posed by the law in her recent article in the Guardian (UK):

Among other things, the law requires all NGOs and associations to comply with burdensome registration procedures, and outlaws those that don’t. Meanwhile, it gives authorities unbounded discretion to approve registration applications, with few substantive guidelines to steer their decisions. There is no appeals process if registration is denied.

The draft is also sloppy – one example being its apparently unlimited scope. It’s unclear whether this aspect was intentional, but the International Centre for Not-for-Profit Law (ICNL) concluded that the law would require “every group of individuals who gather together with a differing level of frequency and perform the broadest variety of imaginable activities, from trekking and football fans, to chess and silk-weaving groups” to register. Failing to do so would be a violation of the law. (So would, apparently, founding an NGO or association without the required number of Cambodian citizen “founding members” required by the law – three and 11, respectively).

The way the law is drafted will make it easy for the government to target and shut down NGOs working on politically sensitive issues (such as, for example, land grabbing). The law will also impair the work of international organizations in Cambodia, as well as the effective disbursement of development aid funding. Without politically independent grassroots organizations operating in Cambodia, donor bodies will be deprived of important informants and partners in the development process.

The law, at first, may seem like a rather dry issue. However, it’s passing could fundamentally change the scene for civil society organizations in Cambodia. These organizations provide a necessary challenge to government action and open a space for citizens – who may feel at risk when dealing directly with government – to express themselves. They also provide important jobs that encourage young people to contribute to their communities, participate in a process of democratic development and become responsible citizens. Organizations like LICADHO protect and empower individuals who speak out against their governments.

It is also important for Canadians to pay attention. CIDA invested $17.03 million into Cambodia in 2010. Without impartial organizations to work with, some of CIDA’s main mandates – such as assisting in land reform – will be unattainable. Addressing such a politicized issue requires an independent civil society.

It should also be self-evident by now that civil society is key to democratic development. I think Hillary Clinton made a realistic assessment of the importance of civil society in a speech at the meeting of Community of Democracies in Krakow, Poland in July 2010:

[...] most countries do have a collection of activists, organizations, congregations, writers, and reporters that work through peaceful means to encourage governments to do better, to do better by their own people. Not all of these organizations or individuals are equally effective, of course. And they do represent a broad range of opinions. And, having been both in an NGO and led NGOs and been in government, I know that it’s sometimes tough to deal with NGOs when you are in the government.

But it doesn’t matter whether the goal is better laws or lower crime or cleaner air or social justice or consumer protection or entrepreneurship and innovation, societies move forward when the citizens that make up these groups are empowered to transform common interests into common actions that serve the common good (emphasis added).

Civil society organizations are helping Cambodians rebuild their nation. Without the pressure these organizations put on the government to respect human rights, the protection they offer to individuals who perform that same function, and the information they provide to development bodies, Cambodians will largely be facing this challenge alone. As Clinton points out, the outcome may be tragic:

[…] along with well-functioning markets and responsible, accountable government, progress in the 21st century depends on the ability of individuals to coalesce around shared goals, and harness the power of their convictions. But when governments crack down on the right of citizens to work together, as they have throughout history, societies fall into stagnation and decay.

Donors are central to preventing the passage of the law. “Continued opposition from western donors and international NGOs is key to preserving Cambodia’s independent civil society. That opposition must be unified, firm, and tied to the two things the government cares about – money and legitimacy,” writes Pilorge. Pressure from individuals and civil society organizations in other countries is also key. Please visit the“Oppose the Cambodian NGO & Associations Law” Facebook Page to learn more about the law.

The content and opinions expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of nor are they endorsed by LICADHO or its affiliates.

traditional justice in Cambodia.

I am considering focusing my McGill-related work while in Cambodia on traditional justice systems in the country, but I have mostly come up against dead-ends in terms of research. My interest in traditional justice is based on research on the gacaca and mato oput systems in Rwanda and Uganda. Is there something similar in Cambodia? If such a structure exists, is there any relationship between the Khmer Rouge atrocities and a traditional justice system? For example, have communities considered using whatever systems might exist now to provide ‘justice’ for victims or is the ECCC the main or only focus? If not, why not?

Fortunately, I spent a couple of hours today with a Cambodian translator (who will remain anonymous) who has a fairly extensive understanding of NGOs working on legal issues in the region, as well as local community conflict resolution systems. It seems that there is a traditional justice system among the indigenous ethnic minority in Cambodia. These communities prefer using the system they have in place because they are not familiar with the local courts. Not being literate, they are also vulnerable to what the court dictates without being aware of the proper procedures. Moreover, with the courts being so corrupt, they cannot meet the costs of winning a case. The translator describes the courts as not belonging to the people, but rather solely to the rich, i.e. those able to pay off the judges. He does not consider the 2010 Anti Corruption Law to have improved the situation.

With that said, it looks like one organization is starting a mediation program for small-scale, local conflicts in Cambodia. It looks like this will probably circulate around family issues and gender-based violence. I have not yet had a chance to follow-up this source, but I will start looking into this angle in the coming weeks. You can also check out this report from the UNDP “A case study of indigenous traditional legal systems and conflict resolution in Cambodia.”

Also, coming back to corruption in Cambodia: from what the translator discussed, it is clear the issue is similar in its core to corruption in Kenya. Police and civil servants are paid a pittance and being paid-off becomes a necessary bonus on their salary if they are to survive. In his community, the translator said he did occasionally offer what he called donations to the police. These donations were announced publicly in front of several policemen to ensure the resources were split between several members. This contribution, he said, is meant to ensure that they can get fuel in their cars and actually patrol the neighbourhoods and respond to calls. From this angle, corruption morphs more into something like a ‘tax,’ without the government being directly involved. I remember a similar narrative in Nairobi: a taxi driver telling me that “chai” or a small pay-off was literally for the policewoman’s cup of evening tea as she sat in a miserable lean-to next to the highway leading to the airport.

If you have any suggestions on where to find more information on traditional justice systems in Cambodia, please contact me at siena.anstis(@)mail.mcgill.ca.

to a close.

First year of law school just came to a slightly unceremonious close. With that said, here are a few words from one of the 1L Contracts professors:

So we’ve just seen some examples where common law judges clearly see there’s a problem but they try to contain the change. They try to make sure this is a very limited reform. That they’re not accused of acting like legislators, as rule makers, lawmakers. But of course you are if you’re a judge. And you are even if you’re in the civil law. Because you establish the interpretation of the law that guides what cases are brought to bar. And generations of judges after you decide cases.

“We have been dealing with this lack of synchronicity for the whole year. And we here of course have the luxury to take a step back from here and say, “Okay, this doesn’t work.” We can read between the lines. “This is unfair, this is unjust, or this is just simply outdated”. The problem is what we do works on two levels. We have here the luxury to step back and be just an observer.

“But at some point, sooner or later, we will be part of this. And all that we learn about those rules, and those principles, is because that’s the language that is spoken by the courts. And that kind of defines the parameters of this language game. But you have to play along, otherwise you’re not being heard. So even if you detest the rules—and I know there were instances where you blamed me for the rules (class laughs), but I’m just the bearer of bad news—you still have to keep in mind that change only works in this incremental fashion. And that in order to take part of this process, you first have to learn the language. But of course, then we’ve seen that even if you work with the rules and work with the language that it’s up to the judges, it seems, what to do with those rules. So the rules seem not to be binding, they seem not to be all that helpful in the end.

“So the question is why are we doing this? Is it something – should we all just slide into cynicism? Now, I told you to lower your expectations (class laughs) but that wasn’t meant in that way. Or are you agreeing with [Oliver Wendell] Holmes? Anyone agreeing with Holmes? He says, well, law, there is no mystery. There are no duties, there are no rights. Law is if the court tells you, you pay, you go to prison, there is a sanction, and rule enforced to back it up. That’s the law. Is that what you’re getting? Is that the sense you’re getting from your courses? (Silence) Guys, do you need a second round of sugar? (class laughs).

“Well, it shouldn’t be.”

“So there seems to be something at work beneath those rules. The question is, what role does this play? If you read Holmes, he says, morality is kitsch. It has no role in the law. And again, this is bare knuckles positivism. Anything that a court decides, and there is no further recourse in the law. But that of course is the most dire sort of cynicism. If we agree that it’s not eventually rules that decide cases but people, then this kind of cynicism leads to conversion of the law. We need to, even if we understand from our observer perspective, that there is this discretion, that it’s people that make the law, and not rules who decide cases. This doesn’t give us the permission to be cynical about the law.

“Law’s not about morals. That’s true. But it’s also not true that there’s nothing underneath this doctrine that is so imperfect and the rules that leave it to the judge. From Holmes, it’s not far to the legal realist stand that it’s prediction of what a judge does. Eventually the law’s nothing but – and I think Jerome Frank said this – law’s nothing but what the judge had for breakfast. If you want to – you can do whatever you like. I wouldn’t go that far.

“All that we do here, all the rules, all the doctrine, is meant to provide a certain minimum standard of equality, justice, fairness. We’ve seen it’s not perfect. But the idea is that the more dense this web is, the more difficult it is for a judge to be completely off the chart. You have to at least justify what you’re doing. And that is what all what we did is about. This rhetorical justification. But that does also not mean that the fact that there is always a rest of discretion, that does not mean that the rule of law is a sham. It doesn’t work in that way that the law tells you what to do. But it communicates you something of what is right and what is wrong that you have to use as an aspiration. And I know, I know, it’s getting kind of sappy… (class laughs).

“One of my own teachers said that the problem of young people nowadays (so that was when I was young): they’re ironically detached. I will ask you just for a moment to let this go. If you don’t take this seriously, then discretion is abused. Now, I’m telling you this as someone who got their first exposure to law in Germany. There, people had impeccable, impeccable legal training. But it was all about the rules and not what lies beyond it. And nobody stood up. And that is what I want you to keep in mind. Just keep it in mind. Underneath all the cynicism, try to still think about that this is about what’s right and what’s wrong. Even in contracts.

“Because contracts matter. Whether it’s your employment, insurance, your home, it matters. That is something that you maybe can take into account for your rest of your lawyerly life. Because,…ah, it’s so sappy, it’s so (class laughs)…now it’s getting worse (class laughs). Seriously, I know it’s boring, it’s painful, it’s reality but this is about being privileged, you guys. And it comes with an obligation, so just try to keep this in mind.

“And now you’ll file out and laugh about me. But I also know that what a first year professor tells you might have a chance of sticking to you. So try to keep this in mind. Beyond all this. Beyond the technicality. Beyond the cynicism. There’s actually something that’s great to be part of. But you have to take it seriously. And not only as the way to make money or something to do because you don’t know what else to do. There’s nothing wrong with making money. Don’t get me wrong. I’m not telling you to all do public interest work. Not all of you will do that. But even if you love making money and you do this, you know maybe keep in mind that at some point, to do a couple pro-bono hours or something like that. So that’s all I have to say to you. It was a pleasure. It’s not that I loved every second of it. (class laughs) But all in all, it was a great course, you did well, it was hard in the end as I said before. We’ll meet again on Thursday, just a technical session…no sappiness, but just preparing for the exam. But this is the end of your first-year contracts course. So thank you.

Cambodian draft NGO & associations law

More coverage on the draft Cambodian NGO and Associations Law. Here’s a fairly extensive and informative article in The Guardian:

The groups argue that the proposed legislation contravenes national and international human rights laws, will make NGOs subject to the whim of the government, and will undermine years of work to strengthen civil society. They also question the need for new legislation, arguing that existing laws are sufficient to govern civil society groups.

This week, 62 NGOs working in Cambodia wrote to government ministers to highlight their concerns following the publication of the second draft of the bill last month. The first draft was published in December. NGOs claim that their earlier concerns had not been taken on board by the government.

The Cambodian government has said the law will allow it to crack down on illegal activities by civil society groups and NGOs operating as a front for terrorist activities. It is understood ministers want the final draft of the law submitted this month, and for it to be passed by the end of the year.

In a briefing paper published when the law was first mooted, the Cambodian League for the Promotion and Defence of Human Rights(Licadho) said the law had “nothing to do with crime, terrorism or transparency, but everything to do with political control”.

[...]

Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch, said the law “could too easily be used to refuse registration or close down organisations that serve the public interest”. He added: “Over the past 20 years the development of civil society has been one of Cambodia’s few enduring achievements. This law threatens to reverse that progress.”

Yap Swee-Seng, executive director of Forum-Asia, said: “When the draft law was first circulated, in December 2010, civil society raised urgent concerns that it would prove vulnerable to abuse by officials at the national, provincial and community level seeking to silence civil society criticism. Far from addressing these fears, the revisions introduced by the government make a bad situation worse.”

Not a convincing distinction.

Indeed, Justine Kagan is right:

In the Supreme Court’s 5-to-4 ruling about a school-choice program in Arizona, Justice Anthony Kennedy’s opinion leaves intact a program that has disbursed almost $350 million of state funds, most of it to schools choosing students on the basis of religion.

The holding all but overrules a landmark decision of the Warren court, Flast v. Cohen. As Justice Elena Kagan says powerfully in her first dissent, “by ravaging Flast in this way,” the majority “damages one of this nation’s defining constitutional commitments.”

The First Amendment’s establishment clause — “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion” — is meant to protect citizens even when they are not harmed. Before, under Flast, a taxpayer could ask a court to enforce this central right. Now, under this ruling, a taxpayer all but can’t, and any government can use the tax system to avoid challenges to financing of religion.

The only difference between cases considered under Flast since 1968 and the current one is the means of government spending. In past cases, it has come through appropriations. In this case, the money comes through a tax credit: any taxpayer can redirect up to $500 of what he or she owes the state to a nonprofit that uses the money for scholarships. What the court calls a tax credit and Arizona calls a voluntary cash contribution is, concretely, a redirected tax payment.

Justice Kennedy, in an opinion clearly intended to overturn legal precedent, says that the program’s financing comes from taxpayers taking advantage of this credit, not from the state, so the taxpayers bringing the lawsuit can claim no harm from the state and lacked standing to sue. To Justice Kagan, “this novel distinction,” has “as little basis in principle as it has in our precedent.” Whether a state finances a program with cash grants or targeted tax breaks, the effect is the same. Taxpayers bear the cost.

Continued.

Human Rights Watch calls for withdrawal of “Flawed Draft NGO and Association Law”

Human Rights Watch is also calling for Cambodia to abandon the draft NGO and Associations Law.

(Bangkok) - Cambodia’s draft law regulating associations and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) should be abandoned because it will undermine rather than promote civil society in the country, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, Forum-Asia, Global Witness, Southeast Asia Press Alliance, Frontline Defenders, and FIDH and OMCT within the framework of the Observatory for the Protection of Human Rights Defenders said today. On April 6, a total of 62 international organizations working in Cambodia called upon the country’s international donors to make strong public and private statements opposing passage of a law that poses the most significant threat to the country’s civil society in many years.

Continued here.

A short background of the law from LICADHO:

The first draft of the law, released on Dec. 15, 2010, was widely condemned by civil society and international observers as an assault on Cambodians’ right to freedom of association, assembly and expression. The second draft, released by the Ministry of Interior on March 24, does nothing to assuage these fears.

Registration is still mandatory for all NGOs and Associations (Article 6). Nonregistered groups are banned from operating. Key provisions are vague and open to arbitrary interpretation. And in many circumstances, the government has carte blanche to shut organizations down without appeal (Article 18 was removed from second draft).

“The law obliterates the concept of independent civil society,” Naly Pilorge, director of LICADHO. “If you look at the law, article by article, then in its entirety, it’s impossible to not conclude that its intent is to control certain civil society groups.”

You can read LICADHO’s Briefing Paper on the Second Draft of the Law here and a press release here.

anti-commons and mud plots in Uganda

Zachary’s article “Mud people and super farmers” might reveal some of the flaws in the anti-commons / gridlock thesis. In particular, Zachary notes the following on a lack of clearly defined property rights among Bukhalo mud plot owners:

Yet costs are clear. The families are mired in mistrust. Interfamily squabbles dominate conflicts and theft of mud is common. Without clear boundaries between mud plots, no one seems responsible for insuring the quarry is flushed with adequate levels of water. No improvements to the quarry have been made. There’s no marketing of the mud. The quarry even lacks a sign.

While he seems to be illustrating a tragedy of the commons issue, it may well be the same situation in a case of clearly defined property rights with legal force. Are clearly defined property rights what necessarily tips the balance and ensures communal profit-making?

He later notes:

The ultimate answer is for government and civil society to mount a comprehensive campaign to title rural land in much the same way as they have done in most African cities, where urban land—and notably private residences—is backed by legal titles that are registered with courts and government agencies.

But, will this do the trick? Do property rights and land titles push people to make an efficient use of a scarce resource? Considering the disorganization reigning in Downtown Kampala, I’m thinking no (although, the qualification of long-term benefits here is likely a subjective exploration).